Los Angeles County has a special talent for turning the most catastrophic failures of its institutions into quiet, procedural footnotes. The November 16th, 2023 crash that nearly wiped out an entire academy class of LASD recruits, Class 464, should have been a defining moment of accountability. Forty individuals hit. Dozens hospitalized. Five in critical condition. One, 19-year-old Recruit Alejandro Martinez, later died from his injuries. And yet here we are, two years later, watching prosecutors float plea deals that would allow the accused driver to avoid a single day of meaningful jail time.
According to sources, the victims appeared in court on November 19th only to learn that the defendant, Nicholas Joseph Gutierrez, who plowed into the formation during a morning training run in Whittier, may walk away with nothing more than probation or a 30-day “tap-and-go” jail stint.
Meanwhile, the families of Class 464 continue to bury the trauma of the most preventable mass-casualty event in recent LASD history.
Originally charged under DA George Gascon, this case continues to drag on with stunning leniency, and the families have been pushed into the background, unheard, unseen, and deliberately sidelined.
The November 19th update represents the clearest signal yet that LA County is preparing to quietly dispose of a case by shrinking it down until it’s barely recognizable.
Families say the court laid out the defense’s three options.
Option one: a DA-offered deal with zero jail time, just probation and the threat of eight years if Gutierrez violates the law in the future.
Option two: a weak court-offered deal of 30 days in jail, a sentence that doesn’t come close to matching the shattered bodies, the months of rehabilitation, or the loss of Recruit Martinez.
Option three: go to trial, an outcome no one believes the county will risk because a courtroom would force inconvenient truths into the public record.
The next hearing is set for January 29. But victims and their families already fear the writing is on the wall: LA County wants this gone.
At the time of the crash, recruits reported the SUV actually accelerated before impact. Multiple witnesses said Gutierrez never even tapped the brakes. LASD leadership initially declared the crash “deliberate,” only to reverse course abruptly. Behind the scenes, sources say Gutierrez’s family connections helped smother the investigation, steering it toward a conveniently vague “medical episode”, a diagnosis never fully explained but quickly embraced because it was the least politically explosive story to sell.
Yet none of that explains how the largest sheriff’s department in the country allowed a training run on a route so dangerously exposed that one wrong move could wipe out half a graduating class.
And none of it explains why, two years later, the families are being forced to accept plea offers that cheapen the life of a dead recruit and the suffering of dozens more.
Class 464 deserves justice, not the silent, bureaucratic grave the County dug to keep this scandal buried forever.
Follow Us