November 19, 2026
5 mins read

Raman Denied Gascón was Her Pick for LAPD Chief. Sources Says Gascón is in the Mix Pushing for Robert Arcos as McDonnell’s Replacement.

Arcos ran the District Attorney’s Bureau of Investigation under Gascón and has twice been a finalist for LAPD chief. The latest account also names a deputy chief in line for promotion, raising questions about who could shape the department’s next command staff.

When word got out in October that Nithya Raman was rumored to be in discussions with George Gascón about becoming the next LAPD chief, the backlash reached a fever pitch at City Hall.

Rank-and-file officers sounded the alarm, former LAPD Chief William Bratton amplified the controversy, and Raman publicly denied that she planned to appoint Gascón to replace Chief Jim McDonnell. She accused the Los Angeles Police Protective League, which backed Mayor Karen Bass, of spreading the story to damage her campaign. The union denied it. Gascón told the Los Angeles Times that he had no interest in the job and had not spoken with Raman or her team.

Now the name circulating is Robert Arcos, the former LAPD assistant chief Gascón put in charge of nearly 300 sworn investigators at the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office during his tenure as LA DA.

The Times reported that LAPD insiders were discussing Arcos as a potential successor to McDonnell. In a post circulating on X, an unnamed LAPD command source said Gascón was actively lobbying for Arcos and that Deputy Chief German Hurtado would immediately be elevated to Assistant Chief if Arcos got the job. A source inside the D.A.’s Office forwarded the post and described the information as “accurate.”

Raman’s denial she wanted Gascón as LAPD Chief only came after the backlash and forced a pivot. That pivot now looks like Gascón is providing his input behind the scenes by pushing Arcos for the Chief’s spot and given his professional history with Arcos, he will likely regain influence over the LAPD through that relationship.  The claim about Hurtado takes the discussion beyond a single appointment. It names a deputy chief who, according to the command source, is already being discussed for a promotion. Arcos told the Times he had had no conversations with Raman’s team. Raman has yet to publicly name Arcos as her choice, and no appointment or promotion has been announced.

Gascón’s History with Arcos

Both men came up through the LAPD and, years apart, ran its Office of Operations. Bratton put Gascón in charge of that office in 2003. Gascón left in 2006 to become police chief in Mesa, Arizona. Arcos joined the LAPD in 1988, rose to assistant chief in 2018 and led the Office of Operations before retiring after 33 years. By then, he had already been a finalist for chief once. In 2018, Mayor Eric Garcetti chose Michel Moore.

In February 2021, less than two months into his term as district attorney, Gascón personally swore in Arcos as chief of the Bureau of Investigation. Gascón publicly praised Arcos as a reform-minded leader and made clear that he was joining the executive team that would carry out the new administration’s agenda. Arcos took command of nearly 300 sworn investigators supporting roughly 1,000 deputy district attorneys. The bureau handled public corruption, fraud, officer-involved shootings and child abductions.

LA DA George Gascon swearing in Robert Arcos in February 2021.

County records show the two appearing together at the L.A. County Police Chiefs’ Association spring conference in 2023 and at a gun violence awareness event in June 2024. That fall, while still running Gascón’s investigative bureau, Arcos made the final three for LAPD chief alongside McDonnell and Emada Tingirides. Bass picked McDonnell. Arcos’s two trips to the final round give him a record of serious consideration for the job. The allegation that Gascón is lobbying for him now adds another question about who is making the case for him this time.

Sources familiar with Arcos’s tenure say he was unpopular with staff while he oversaw the D.A.’s sworn investigators. However, Gascón paints a very different picture praising Arcos’s ability to build relationships when he hired him.

The Internal Affairs Investigation That Resurfaced

In 2006, when Arcos was an LAPD lieutenant, his daughter killed two people in a drunk-driving crash on the 5 Freeway. She was convicted of vehicular manslaughter and sentenced to seven years in prison. The allegation involving Arcos was that he asked the county Probation Department to alter a report in her favor. Arcos denied intervening, and LAPD Internal Affairs cleared him.

David Pokorny, the lead California Highway Patrol investigator in the crash, told the Times he had no proof Arcos pressured Probation. He also said Internal Affairs never interviewed him. The case surfaced publicly while Arcos was a finalist in 2018, and then-Police Commission President Steve Soboroff said Arcos should have disclosed it during his interview. The head of the commission that helped select the finalists said he learned about the matter from a newspaper story.

A separate allegation surfaced after his daughter’s second DUI case in 2015. The other driver sued her and her parents and alleged, among other things, that Arcos used his LAPD position to secure a lighter sentence. Arcos denied influencing the case. The D.A.’s Office told the Times that her earlier convictions could not legally be used to elevate the new charge to a felony. The final disposition of the civil lawsuit remains unverified.

Arcos now holds a senior position in the same county department that figured in the 2006 allegation. After Nathan Hochman defeated Gascón in November 2024, The Current Report reported that Arcos had moved to L.A. County Probation as deputy director of special enforcement operations. The December 6 report also described a memo indicating Chief Probation Officer Guillermo Viera Rosa planned to step down at the end of the month, amid scrutiny of the department’s leadership and conditions in its juvenile facilities. Four days later, Probation announced that Viera Rosa had decided to stay. The department now lists Arcos as its chief deputy of operations.

McDonnell’s Refusal to Interfere with ICE Operations

On June 10, 2025, Councilwoman Imelda Padilla asked McDonnell whether the LAPD could warn elected officials before federal immigration operations in their districts. McDonnell stopped to clarify exactly what she meant. Was she asking him to notify her before another law enforcement agency carried out an operation? Padilla confirmed that she was. McDonnell refused and told her that giving that kind of advance warning would amount to “obstruction of justice.” The Current Report published footage of the exchange two days later.

 

Raman participated in the meeting. The public record does not establish that she joined Padilla’s request or that McDonnell’s refusal prompted her pledge to replace him. During the campaign, Raman said McDonnell had “failed to meet the moment” and had lost public trust, criticizing the LAPD’s response to the federal immigration crackdown and its tactics against protesters. McDonnell defended his officers’ response, citing the threats they faced and the injuries they suffered. Raman has made her judgment of McDonnell public.

The command source cited by Film The Police LA also claimed McDonnell has stepped up his public appearances to protect his position. McDonnell has publicly made his preference clear. At a November 18 briefing on Olympic security, he said he hoped to stay through the 2028 Games and described his conversations with Raman as productive. Raman spokesperson Liz Garcia told LAist the mayor-elect intends to appoint a new chief and will weigh continuity of city services in deciding when.

The City Charter gives the Police Commission and City Council separate procedures for removing a sitting chief. A permanent successor goes through open recruitment. The commission sends ranked recommendations to the mayor, and the City Council votes on confirmation. If Arcos advances, commissioners and council members can ask him on the record whether Gascón has advocated for him, whether anyone has discussed promoting Hurtado, and whether he would seek Gascón’s advice on personnel or policy. They can also ask Arcos what he disclosed during his earlier vetting and hear from the investigators who served under him.

The October backlash over Gascón’s rumored appointment as LAPD chief forced Raman to change course. Gascón was a failed one-term D.A. whom even uber-progressive megadonor George Soros wouldn’t back for a second term. Now it seems Raman has found a way around the backlash by turning to Robert Arcos, a close colleague who worked under Gascón at the D.A.’s office. If Raman gets her way, she’ll have puppets in place who might actually be stupid enough to do what McDonnell refused to do –  OBSTRUCT JUSTICE.

Cece Woods

Cece Woods

Cece Woods is an independent investigative journalist and Editor-in-Chief of The Current Report, specializing in public corruption, institutional accountability, and high-profile criminal and civil cases.

Previous Story

Sheriff Luna’s Fleet Crisis: Mechanics Walk Out, Leaving Aging Vehicles Unusable and Public Safety in Jeopardy

Latest from Blog

Go toTop