In a move dripping with irony – and political calculation – Los Angeles County Sheriff Robert Luna has penned a seven-page letter to U.S. District Judge Stephen V. Wilson asking for leniency in the sentencing of Deputy Trevor Kirk. This, after Luna’s own administration cooperated with federal prosecutors to secure Kirk’s conviction for excessive use of force in a case that has rocked the law enforcement community.
The letter, dated May 14, 2025, reads like a masterclass in bureaucratic blame-shifting. Luna acknowledges the jury’s verdict but insists that Kirk’s actions were not entirely his fault, citing “systemic failures” in the Department stretching back years before he took office. Essentially, Luna is asking the court to go easy on Kirk because of the department’s longstanding dysfunction—a dysfunction Luna himself was elected to fix.
Yet, as The Current Report detailed, Luna’s “leadership” has been more about optics than accountability. Under his watch, a historic staffing crisis has gutted morale, suicides have spiked, and political pandering to the Board of Supervisors has taken precedence over supporting rank-and-file deputies. Luna’s letter attempts to paint a picture of a reform-minded sheriff cleaning up a mess he inherited. But the facts tell a different story.
Kirk was convicted of deploying pepper spray on a suspect in what the jury deemed an excessive and unconstitutional use of force. This federal conviction sets a dangerous precedent for law enforcement officers nationwide, effectively criminalizing split-second decisions made in the field. It’s the kind of prosecutorial overreach that should have Luna’s office up in arms defending his deputies. Instead, the department cooperated with federal investigators, providing the very documentation that helped convict one of their own.
Now, with the political winds shifting and union support waning, Luna is trying to play both sides – claiming to respect the court’s decision while simultaneously pleading for mercy. His letter extensively cites failures in the Settlement Agreement (SA) with the Department of Justice, highlighting outdated use-of-force policies and inadequate training at Lancaster and Palmdale stations, where Kirk was assigned. Luna even goes so far as to quote Monitoring Team reports that eviscerate his own department’s leadership and compliance failures.
But here’s the kicker: these systemic issues were not new revelations. They were well-documented long before Luna took office, and his administration has had over two years to address them. Instead of decisive action, Luna’s tenure has been marred by more finger-pointing and politically safe photo ops, rather than substantive reforms.
Luna’s request for probation as the “best suited” outcome for Kirk’s rehabilitation rings hollow. If he truly believed in supporting his deputies, why did his department facilitate the prosecution in the first place? The answer is simple: it was politically expedient.
Defense attorney Tom Yu didn’t hold back when addressing the racial narrative swirling around Deputy Kirk’s case. “The race card gets abused by a lot of people,” Yu said bluntly. “Yes, there’s racism in this country — like in every other country. But this is still the greatest country in the world. I’d die for it. Unfortunately, radical groups have made a sport out of weaponizing race for their own agendas, and that’s exactly what’s happening here.”
Yu made it clear: race has no business being a factor in this case. What should matter is the fact that Kirk had a clean, unblemished record before this incident. And more importantly, Yu dropped a reality check the media conveniently sidesteps — the plea deal everyone’s screaming about? It’s not some hush-hush backroom favor.
“Deputy Kirk was offered a misdemeanor plea with no jail time back in December 2024 — two months before trial,” Yu said. “This was always on the table. Let me repeat that: always. It’s up to the U.S. Attorney to offer it, and they did. This isn’t a surprise twist. It’s standard procedure, whether people like it or not.”
In other words, the virtue-signaling hysteria over this so-called “leniency” is nothing more than political theater — a scripted spectacle for public consumption, ignoring the facts that blow their narrative apart.
As the department faces an exodus of personnel and a credibility crisis, Luna’s latest plea reveals the contradiction at the heart of his leadership. He wants the accolades of a reformer while avoiding the political cost of standing up for his own. Unfortunately for Deputy Kirk, he is now a casualty of that balancing act.
The devil is, indeed, in the details.
Follow Us